This leading article appeared today in El
País (here).
Impunity
in London
EL PAÍS - Opinion - 19-07-2006
One year after the London police killed a young Brazilian in error in
the Underground when they mistook him for a terrorist (if it can be said to be
killing in error after a man has been followed for a long time by one of the
best-trained forces in the world and is finished off by firing seven shots at point-blank
range), the prosecution has concluded that nobody will be tried for the death
of the electrician Jean-Charles de Menezes. There is no evidence to accuse any
member of the police with murder, or even with homicide.
The archiving of the case by British justice is unacceptable from any
point of view, even though the event took place in the circumstances of extreme
tension that London was living in a year ago. In the death of Menezes (on 22
July, the day after a triple attack in the Underground failed because of the
failure of the explosives and two weeks after the terrorist massacre
perpetrated by British Muslim fanatics that left 52 dead and 700 injured) there
was a series of blunders and confusion from the police. But the prosecution has
decided, to the general applause of the political class, that the police of the
British capital will only face administrative charges which will presumably end
in a fine for breaching the health and safety legislation in its provisions
about protection of the citizens.
Hardly anything went right in the police assessment of the situation and
its chain of command. From mistaking Menezes for one of the terrorists who had
failed in an attack in the Underground the evening before, and who lived in the
same building, to the presumption, because of his “bulky” clothing, that he was
carrying explosives. There was also, according to the police officers involved,
an alleged resistance to authority before he was riddled with bullets,
motionless, with shots to the head, even though the head of the antiterrorist
unit denies that she had given her men the order to kill the Brazilian
whom they had tragically mistaken. The head of one of the most renowned police
forces in the world, Ian Blair, maintained for two days afterwards that Menezes
was a suicide terrorist.
When
such a string of nonsensical acts ends in the despicable death of an innocent
man and the events take place in a country that is considered as a beacon of
democratic liberties, people among the security forces or among the politicians
with authority over them must be called to account. This has not been the case.
Apart from the acquittal without trial decided on Monday by the prosecutor, no
police officer has resigned in London over the death of Menezes, nor has any
member of Tony Blair’s Labour Government. The stupor of the family of the young
Brazilian is understandable.
Meanwhile, today’s
Süddeutsche Zeitung has a 900-word article entitled Barons for a bundle of
cash (here).
So much for
Blairs’ (sic) Britain and its image in the world.
Recent Comments